Dark

Why Dark Video Is A Terrible Blocky Mess

Tom Scott
Subscribe
Views 1 671 994
99% 16 657 63

Dark scenes in television, RUvid, and streaming platforms all look pixelated and blocky. Here's why.
Animation by William Marler: wmad.co.uk
I'm at tomscott.com
on Twitter at twitter.com/tomscott
on Facebook at facebook.com/tomscott
and on Instagram as tomscottgo

Published on

 

Mar 30, 2020

Share:

Link:

Download:

Loading link...

Add to:

My playlist
Watch later
Comments 80
Tom Scott
Tom Scott 2 months ago
I can promise there are no jump-scares in here. And yes, I finally got an animator to do in a couple of days what would have taken me a couple of weeks...!
Elijah
Elijah 22 days ago
fantastic animation!
Gaia Carney
Gaia Carney Month ago
Tom Scott - great job! I especially enjoyed that bit of reverb added when you were ‘in’ the empty theatre 🎭 cool cool cool 😎
jiffy pop
jiffy pop Month ago
great video, but most industry standard movie cameras use 12bit colour or higher
giant woman
giant woman Month ago
this was so well written
Kringey Noty
Kringey Noty Month ago
Even your comment isn't make sense(1 month ago) while this video (3 weeks ago)?
Hold my beef stew
Hold my beef stew 5 hours ago
Literally thought this video was gonna talk about dark web stuff
Efensie music
Efensie music 12 hours ago
i think that auto noise reduction thing you put in the video is too high the audio sounds strange
Linux Streamer
Linux Streamer 16 hours ago
this block thing i always see it on the skyrim loading screens
El Mojo
El Mojo 19 hours ago
He's talking about the Battle of Winterfell, right?
Tim Ramich
Tim Ramich 3 days ago
8 bit RGB color is plenty. Video doesn't have 256 values per color for 8 bit YUV spaces. It's limited to 16 to 235. Video compression is the secondary problem. 10 bit video solves it, and newer color spaces also add to the help.
Lord Grompulus
Lord Grompulus 3 days ago
3:22 but it is clearly visibile isnt it?
Swirly Rick
Swirly Rick 3 days ago
amazing editing
Kimmstin Y.
Kimmstin Y. 3 days ago
I am watching this in 144p and it is even blockier
Jordan Ferrazza
Jordan Ferrazza 4 days ago
Sometimes, particularly during the pandemic, the background falls asleep then gets noticeably compressed.
eden gourley
eden gourley 4 days ago
POLYGON! YAY!
The Ruler
The Ruler 4 days ago
The Royal game of ur
Darkphenix Channel
You have no idea how much I hate this dark effect when I tried to make an Alien Roller Coaster. Super dark, too much for RUvid
Jared Franklin
Jared Franklin 5 days ago
My monitor has so much colour banding does anyone know if there’s anything to do about it
H,o DEFNDERR
H,o DEFNDERR 5 days ago
I got scared
PhonicBoom/ CosmicLatte
The editing in this in incredible 🤯
Petr K
Petr K 6 days ago
Your second reason is not really valid thanks to something called "gamma" (not sure, but I think you already had a video about that and in that case I don't know why you brought up the second point). Brightness levels are not linear so with increase from 200 to 201 you get way higher brightness increase than from 1 to 2. Btw - dithering is not an option even in bright areas - it is basically random noise (should be, not alway really is) and that is incompressible.
Pluuton
Pluuton 7 days ago
What a hell to edit, but great vid
jekkt
jekkt 7 days ago
i think this is a great artistic tool. it has a certain aesthetic to it.
Gabriel Dirie
Gabriel Dirie 7 days ago
This happend a lot in GoT's "the long night", question is, taking in account that there are 4k screens nowadays, is it possible to increase the number of colours?
Uncharted Gaming
Uncharted Gaming 7 days ago
This guy makes my brain hurt
Rev. James C
Rev. James C 7 days ago
Good that you got an animator, because this would be a headache to put together. I have a headache after watching it. Off to bed to recover.
MrSBGames
MrSBGames 7 days ago
Tom must have not experienced 4k hdr....
JDiel
JDiel 7 days ago
I just watch this video in 144p and didnt notice because i thought it is the whole point of the video
eboyeezy 24
eboyeezy 24 8 days ago
I just cant beleive this guy is good at everyting....ormaybe he's the last descendant of Albert Eistien
Kerbal Krusher
Kerbal Krusher 8 days ago
is it just me or is the color banding at 3:19 very noticable
Isaac Alonzo
Isaac Alonzo 8 days ago
SloMo Guys broke the RUvid compression with glitter 😂
GenXUnderground
GenXUnderground 9 days ago
You should've seen how bad Game of Thrones looked on HBO Nordic.
- fsendventd
- fsendventd 9 days ago
"up to 60 times a second" *cries in 240Hz gaming monitor*
- fsendventd
- fsendventd 20 hours ago
@Flashlight i mean i don't actually have a 240hz monitor but they exist
Flashlight
Flashlight Day ago
at least your refresh rate is a multiple of 60 mine is 75hz
Fredrick reloaded
Fredrick reloaded 10 days ago
thanks I hate myself now
VCuber X
VCuber X 10 days ago
im able to see color banding on a standard 8-bit color screen, am i going to be ok
Leaf Axe
Leaf Axe 10 days ago
A bit harder to notice with AMOLED.
Who Stole My Toast
Who Stole My Toast 11 days ago
This video destroyed my eyesight
Atronicks [GD]
Atronicks [GD] 12 days ago
Is it weird that I can see the banding on the bright blue background.
Omar Smith
Omar Smith 13 days ago
Very well explained on a level everyone can understand
Matrix Teknologies [Joseph Clarke]
this why i hate dark movies, they suck on modern tv when you add theses issues
AlexBale
AlexBale 14 days ago
Your videos are amazing. I've binge-watched them since the beginning of the lockdown 😅
Mitchell BURGESS
Mitchell BURGESS 14 days ago
If you want to see the difference for yourself and you have an iPhone , take a screenshot at 3:24 save edit photo turn the contrast all the way up and then turn the brightness all the way up on the photos it’s cool
skuqre
skuqre 14 days ago
tom i feel dirty
Paul Cutcliffe
Paul Cutcliffe 15 days ago
Brilliant, video, as usual. Keep up the good work, Tom! 😊
ᛋ ᛋ Rxin
ᛋ ᛋ Rxin 15 days ago
1:18 *just add some 💯 & 😂 emojis and you’ll be a deep fried Tom*
HerbertElayda
HerbertElayda 16 days ago
I pretend that I understand this video.
james dean
james dean 16 days ago
That game of thrones episode" the long night" made me realize why a dark war scene needs very high resolution to just even barely make out the details.
Night Bleeding
Night Bleeding 17 days ago
There is one big thing that i might not known why youtube is recommending me all shetty stufs that i never searched for .
nonsequiturm
nonsequiturm 17 days ago
I notice this all the time. It's one of the reasons I still buy movies on physical mediums.
Feakre
Feakre 17 days ago
This is why analogue signals are better than digital signals, I've been saying this for years. A good strong analogue TV signal will knock spots off an analogue signal for quality but according to the government who switched off analogue, digital is better.
elliott mariess
elliott mariess 17 days ago
i’ve always noticed that there’s a lot of extra compression in the red channel on videos. often scenes in films that use mostly red look awful compared to the rest of the film. anybody have any insight why red is always the worst colour for compression?
Hacher Unfriended
Hacher Unfriended 17 days ago
Watched this video in 144p
Lucas Gatrell
Lucas Gatrell 18 days ago
Brb, going to watch 256 shades of grey before continuing
Maximilian Schäffler
3:25 I can see those color banding things and there are everywhere!! Even when its bright games movies apps... I just ist the worst
Mustafa Mazin
Mustafa Mazin 18 days ago
I still see color banding even on height brightness
Abedalrahman Shehabi
Correction: There are 24 bits per pixel. The red, green, and blue lights in a pixel each have 8 bits.
Space_Ninja
Space_Ninja 19 days ago
I hate the dark I get hella scared which means if I hear something I raise my fist and get ready to fight
ZeroTheHero
ZeroTheHero 19 days ago
I actually knew all this but I enjoyed watching anyway!
Onion Pie
Onion Pie 20 days ago
Up to 60 times a second? 240 hz monitors be laughing rn
Luke Jones
Luke Jones 20 days ago
Every frame of this video is a masterpiece, love the effort Tom
⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻
The menacingly eerie thumbnail can become a dank meme real fast...
AnasMations
AnasMations 21 day ago
FINALLY, Oil fried Tom Scott! 1:17
Nessolfte
Nessolfte 22 days ago
At 3:28 when Tom is describing why you can't see the bands, and after he's already showed you what it could look like, I see lots of semicircular banding. It's distracting. Is this because of a possible technical error when they created the video? Is Tom showing what should be invisible banding but accidentally set the colors wrong? I wonder if anyone else has the same problem. To be fair, I always notice the black banding, too.
Ayden Szymczak
Ayden Szymczak 22 days ago
"is my monitor a waste of money"
Pervah
Pervah 22 days ago
This video hurts to watch
Ajax
Ajax 22 days ago
All comes down to money...
Ant On
Ant On 22 days ago
256 shades of grey.
Grimlinz
Grimlinz 23 days ago
Can anyone else see the colorbanding on bright backgrounds without even having to zoom in?
jasonwhat
jasonwhat 23 days ago
anyone else see color banding at 3:22 even without the zoom in?
Smith Gaming
Smith Gaming 23 days ago
My phone is at 1%
DetectiveLevi
DetectiveLevi 24 days ago
Bruh im on 144p
Sam TGF
Sam TGF 24 days ago
Damm that jumpscare at 6:10 really got me lmao
Xeom
Xeom 24 days ago
I'm colorblind 😬
Well Silver
Well Silver 24 days ago
A expensive HDR monitor isnt going to fix that crappy youtube video Samsung: I MADE TECH THAT DOES THAT ARE YOU MOCKING ME?
Satya Adt
Satya Adt 24 days ago
Absolutely brilliant and without frills. You just won a subscriber.
Infinite Sheldon
Infinite Sheldon 24 days ago
OMG thank you this was driving me nuts
Lost Evesy
Lost Evesy 24 days ago
They can update more than 60 times a second
Bebo Ahmed
Bebo Ahmed 25 days ago
You look like one of those baldi's basics chars in thumbnail
avarage guy
avarage guy 25 days ago
My phone says 24 bits Does that mean 24 bits per pixel?
- Garugaa -
- Garugaa - 25 days ago
4:50 Thats why NoCopyrightSounds’ purple circle’s doesnt look great
Scias
Scias 25 days ago
What are the solutions?
CRINGE LORD
CRINGE LORD 26 days ago
but I don't care
Simone LastName
Simone LastName 23 days ago
So why did you watch this video?
Petar Ratković
Petar Ratković 26 days ago
I watched all videos on Computerphile featuring Tom, and I just now found out he's got his own channel. What a joy.
Pipe Dream
Pipe Dream 26 days ago
Will HDMI 2.1 fix this issue because of the faster transfer speeds?
Next videos
This Video Has 12,537,801 Views
10:39
hangman is a weird game
19:30
LAY '莲 (Lit)' MV
5:18
Views 2 668 243